Former Wells Fargo Executive Dodges Jail Time in Fake Accounts Scandal

Carrie Tolstedt, former Wells Fargo executive, has been sentenced to three years’ probation for her pivotal role in the bank’s notorious fake-accounts scandal.

by Faruk Imamovic
SHARE
Former Wells Fargo Executive Dodges Jail Time in Fake Accounts Scandal
© Getty Images News/Justin Sullivan

Carrie Tolstedt, former Wells Fargo executive, has been sentenced to three years’ probation for her pivotal role in the bank’s notorious fake-accounts scandal. Tolstedt's case is yet another reminder of the rare prison sentences meted out to high-level executives, even amidst multi-billion-dollar scandals.

Obstruction of Regulators' Investigation

Tolstedt had willingly chosen to plead guilty to the charge of obstructing regulators’ in-depth investigation into the bank. This plea came after her departure from the bank in 2016, the very year the scandal unraveled in full public view.

In a bid to avoid a more severe penalty, her defense argued for probation, inclusive of six months under home confinement. Prosecutors, on the other hand, were eyeing a 12-month prison sentence. CNN notes that over the span of eight years, Wells Fargo has dug deep into its pockets, spending billions in settlements related to this scandal, with Tolstedt at the center of these allegations.

Financial Repercussions and Rare Consequences for Executives

While Tolstedt has been the singular executive from Wells Fargo to face criminal charges concerning this scandal, her financial settlements are staggering. She paid a whopping $17 million to settle a civil case with the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency (OCC).

This was followed by another $3 million in settlements with the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC). Despite the scandal, Tolstedt’s exit from Wells Fargo came with a golden parachute — a retirement package totaling $125 million.

The bank, however, has since retracted approximately $67 million from this sum. Highlighting the rarity of prison sentences for top-tier executives, it's notable that only one individual from Wall Street has been incarcerated due to actions precipitating the 2008 financial crisis.

To put it into perspective, the last prominent executive to serve prison time for financial discrepancies was Jeff Skilling, former Enron CEO. Skilling was handed a 12-year sentence post the monumental collapse of the energy conglomerate in 2001.

SHARE