Shaken Trust: Did Google's Earthquake Warning System Fail in Turkey?

Google's revolutionary earthquake warning system, designed for Android devices, was heralded as a critical step forward in disaster preparation.

by Faruk Imamovic
SHARE
Shaken Trust: Did Google's Earthquake Warning System Fail in Turkey?

Google's revolutionary earthquake warning system, designed for Android devices, was heralded as a critical step forward in disaster preparation. The system was engineered to alert users promptly, allowing them to seek safety in case of imminent seismic events.

However, reports emerging from Turkey on February 6 suggest that this technology may not have lived up to its promising start.

Quaking Questions Over Early Warnings

Investigative journalists from the BBC conducted extensive interviews with hundreds of people across three Turkish cities.

Their findings painted a troubling picture: not a single individual reported receiving a warning ahead of the first earthquake. Only a "limited number" of respondents noted getting a notification about the subsequent seismic event.

Such findings raise alarming questions about the reliability and effectiveness of Google's technology. As Professor Harold Tobin, director of the Pacific Northwest Seismic Network, argued, "If Google makes a promise, or makes an implicit promise, to deliver a service like earthquake early warning, then to me, it raises the stakes." He further asserted, "They have a responsibility to be able to follow through on something that is directly related to life and limb." Despite these concerns, Google maintains the system functioned as expected.

Micah Berman, Google's product lead on the system, confidently stated to the BBC, "We are confident that this system fired and sent alerts."

The Android Earthquake Alert System: A Deep Dive

The Android Earthquake Alert System employs the accelerometer—a motion detection sensor—in smartphones to generate alerts.

The concept behind the system is ingeniously simple: if multiple phones vibrate simultaneously, Google collects this data to pinpoint the earthquake's epicenter and estimate its magnitude. It then automatically sends an alert to people likely to experience ground shaking.

Despite the narrow window—less than a minute between the warning and the actual tremors—the technology can potentially aid individuals in regions lacking conventional warning systems. However, the doubt cast by the recent 7.8 magnitude earthquake in Turkey raises critical questions about the system's reliability.

Even if the system did operate as intended, assessing its success is challenging due to the lack of data on how many people should have been notified and how many actually received warnings in such instances, not to mention during less severe occurrences.

Google
SHARE