US Citizens No Longer Want to Fight and Lay Down Their Lives for Their Homeland

"If you look at our history, we have to be convinced to go to war," David Justice, executive director of military recruitment experts, told Newsweek

by Sededin Dedovic
US Citizens No Longer Want to Fight and Lay Down Their Lives for Their Homeland
© Chung Sung-Jun / Getty Images

A significant portion of American adults would be hesitant to enlist in the military in the event of a major war, according to a recent survey, reflecting a decline in public confidence in the armed forces. In recent years, all branches of the military have faced challenges meeting recruitment targets, indicating a growing disinterest in pursuing a military career.

In 2023, both the Army and Air Force fell short of their targets by approximately 10,000 recruits, while the Navy was 6,000 recruits below its goal. Since 1987, the number of active personnel has decreased by 39 percent. This shortage is raising concerns among experts, especially given the current volatile global landscape.

"Currently, we have strike groups and aircraft carriers, including a Marine Expeditionary Force near Israel," noted Justin Henderson, a former US Marine transport operator turned military recruiter, in an interview with Newsweek.

"We're funding two wars, yet we have boots on the ground and drones over Gaza. This is a very tumultuous time for us as we navigate these uncertainties." The uncertainty is further underscored by the fact that recruitment shortfalls are occurring during a period of heightened geopolitical tension.

Tom Shugart, a senior fellow at the Center for a New American Security and a former submarine captain, expressed his concerns, particularly regarding the time required to train personnel for crucial roles such as submarine and aircraft operations.

While the challenges in recruitment are multifaceted, experts highlight the need for the military to adapt its messaging to resonate with a younger generation immersed in modern technology. Alleged "conscious" marketing strategies are also identified as potential obstacles.

Additionally, the economic landscape plays a role, as the military historically faces fewer recruitment challenges during economic downturns when unemployment rates are high. An Echelon Insights poll conducted between Oct.

23 and 26 revealed that 72 percent of likely voters would be unwilling to volunteer for military service in the event of a major conflict, compared to 21 percent who would, with the remainder uncertain. Tom Shugart emphasized the need to contextualize these results, noting that public willingness to serve can be influenced by the reasons for entering a conflict.

David Justice, executive director of military recruitment experts, highlighted historical patterns, noting that public support for wars has varied depending on the perceived justifications. Economic factors also come into play, with higher unemployment rates historically correlating with increased military enlistments.

The military's efforts to appeal to a younger demographic have faced criticism, particularly initiatives like hiring a drag queen, Harpy Daniels, as a digital ambassador, and featuring transgender soldier Rachel Jones. Despite targeting a more "informed" section of society, these attempts have sparked controversy.

Justin Henderson emphasized the need for the military to communicate effectively with the youth, acknowledging that the popular perception influenced by Hollywood often focuses on action-packed scenarios involving Navy SEALs, whereas the majority of military roles are support-oriented.