Joe Biden vs. Benjamin Netanyahu on the Fate of Gaza!

In the intricate and often tense landscape of Middle East politics, the idea of a two-state solution remains a focal point of international diplomacy.

by Faruk Imamovic
Joe Biden vs. Benjamin Netanyahu on the Fate of Gaza!
© Getty Images

In the intricate and often tense landscape of Middle East politics, the idea of a two-state solution remains a focal point of international diplomacy. The recent phone conversation between U.S. President Joe Biden and Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has brought this topic back into the limelight.

During their discussion, Netanyahu clarified his previous comments about the Palestinian state, which appeared to reject its formation. This dialogue underscores the ongoing efforts and challenges in achieving peace in the region.

The Vision of a Demilitarized Palestinian State

Central to their conversation was the concept of a future Palestinian state. Biden, known for his long-standing familiarity with Middle East politics, finds the idea of a demilitarized Palestinian state "intriguing." This notion, while not new, has gained traction in recent discussions.

The concept involves a Palestinian state with either no military force or a significantly limited one, aimed at ensuring security for both Israel and the proposed Palestinian state. This approach is seen as a potential path towards a two-state solution, a longstanding objective in Middle Eastern diplomacy.

The Biden administration's commitment to this vision was evident in the president's comments to the press. He highlighted the existence of several countries and states within the United Nations that either do not possess a military or have limited military capabilities.

Biden's remarks, though not laying out a specific plan, indicate an openness to exploring various models of a two-state solution.

Mahmoud Abbas© Getty Images/Spencer Platt

The Role of International Actors in Shaping the Middle East Peace Process

In the intricate puzzle of the Middle East peace process, the influence of international actors is undeniable.

This dynamic is not just a bilateral affair between the United States and Israel but involves a broader spectrum of global players whose interests and actions significantly impact the region's stability. Egyptian President Abdel Fattah al-Sisi's recent public advocacy for a demilitarized Palestinian state exemplifies this international dimension.

His suggestion of deploying NATO, United Nations, Arab, or American forces to ensure security for both the nascent Palestinian state and Israel adds another layer to the discussion. It reflects the potential for a multinational approach to ensure peace and security in the region.

Similarly, European nations and other members of the international community have shown varying degrees of involvement and interest in resolving the Israel-Palestine conflict. The European Union, for instance, has been a vocal advocate for a two-state solution, emphasizing the importance of direct negotiations between Israel and Palestine.

Furthermore, countries like Russia and China, while less vocal, also hold significant diplomatic influence and have their own perspectives and interests in the region. The involvement of the Arab League and its member states, particularly those who have recently normalized relations with Israel, such as the United Arab Emirates and Bahrain, could also play a crucial role.

These countries could provide a unique perspective, balancing their newfound relationships with Israel and traditional support for the Palestinian cause. This multiplicity of actors underscores the complexity of the Middle East peace process.

Each brings its own set of interests, perspectives, and diplomatic leverage, making the path to a lasting solution not just a matter of bilateral agreements but a mosaic of international diplomacy and strategic alliances.

Challenges and Divergent Views

Despite these discussions, the path to peace remains fraught with obstacles. Biden and Netanyahu's public disagreement over the future of Gaza and the wider Israel-Hamas conflict reflects the complexity of the situation.

The Biden administration, including Secretary of State Antony Blinken, has emphasized the importance of a Palestinian state for achieving lasting peace and stability in the Middle East. However, Netanyahu's stance, particularly his insistence on Israel's need for security control over territories, presents a significant challenge to these aspirations.

The recent war in Gaza and Netanyahu's political challenges within Israel add further layers to this complex scenario. The Israeli Prime Minister faces internal pressures, exemplified by the protests in Tel Aviv by family members of hostages held by Hamas and calls for fresh elections by Israeli war cabinet minister Gadi Eisenkot.

The contrast between Biden's support for Israel and the rising controversy around Israel's military actions in Gaza highlights the delicate balance the U.S. seeks to maintain. Public sentiment, particularly among younger voters and Arab Americans, has been shifting, posing a challenge to the U.S.

administration's approach towards Israel.

A Diplomatic Tightrope

Despite these challenges, the U.S. and Israel continue to navigate their relationship carefully. Biden's recent support for Israel post-October 7 attacks and his private discussions with Netanyahu signify an effort to manage differences discreetly.

The U.S. strategy involves counseling and, at times, critiquing Israel's war decisions while avoiding public confrontation. This approach is aimed at maintaining a constructive relationship while addressing the complexities of the conflict.

As senior U.S. officials seek to downplay Netanyahu's rejection of a Palestinian state, the path to a two-state solution remains unclear. Biden, acknowledging the difficulty of this endeavor, remains committed to pursuing candid and forthright discussions with Israel.

The recent conversations between Biden and Netanyahu, while not yielding immediate solutions, highlight the ongoing diplomatic efforts and the intricate dance of international relations in one of the world's most volatile regions.

Joe Biden Benjamin Netanyahu