New York Community Bank Faces Crisis: Shares Plunge to Historic Low

New York Community Bank (NYCB) has found itself in troubled waters as its shares plummeted 23% on Monday, marking the lowest level since 1996.

by Faruk Imamovic
SHARE
New York Community Bank Faces Crisis: Shares Plunge to Historic Low
© Getty Images/Spencer Platt

New York Community Bank (NYCB) has found itself in troubled waters as its shares plummeted 23% on Monday, marking the lowest level since 1996. This dramatic decline follows a harrowing week for the bank, which disclosed "material weakness" in its controls in a recent filing.

This admission has had a profound impact, leading to a staggering $2.4 billion loss for shareholders in the last quarter alone. The bank's troubles were compounded on Friday when its stock slid more than 25% in the wake of these revelations and a subsequent major leadership shakeup that saw Alessandro DiNello stepping in as the new president and CEO.

Ratings Downgrade and Delayed Financial Disclosures

The bank's woes were exacerbated by a downgrade from Fitch Ratings, which relegated NYCB’s debt to junk status, a sentiment echoed by Moody’s Investors Service with a further downgrade into junk territory.

Adding to the uncertainty, NYCB announced a delay in releasing its annual financial disclosure, the 10-K report, opting instead to focus on rectifying the identified issues. This delay, with a new expected filing date of March 15, raises concerns reminiscent of First Republic Bank's scenario, which faced a similar situation shortly before its failure last year.

The recent updates have cast a shadow over the bank's financial health, especially after NYCB reported a surprising loss of $252 million last quarter, a stark contrast to the $172 million profit in the same quarter of the previous year.

This loss led to a significant drop in stock value, reaching levels not seen since 1997. Despite the downturn, the bank attempted to stabilize depositor and investor confidence by affirming that deposits had remained stable and even saw a slight increase in the last quarter of 2023.

The Bigger Picture for Regional Banks

The ripple effects of NYCB's struggles have been felt across the regional banking sector, albeit with mixed outcomes. For instance, shares of Valley National Bank and Zions Bancorporation experienced varying levels of impact, with the former closing 5.6% lower and the latter managing a 1% increase on Monday.

The KBW Regional Banking Index itself saw a modest decline of 0.7%, indicating a broader concern within the regional banking industry. The language used by NYCB to describe its internal issues mirrors the analyses conducted in the wake of the collapses of Silicon Valley Bank and Signature Bank, suggesting a systemic issue of ineffective oversight and risk assessment within the banking sector.

With NYCB shares down over 70% year to date, the industry and observers alike are watching closely to see how this will affect the landscape of regional banking and whether the measures taken by NYCB will be enough to steer it back to stability.

New York
SHARE