Potential Conviction Could Lead Donald Trump to Probation Review

Donald Trump Faces Unusual Challenges in Manhattan Hush Money Trial

by Faruk Imamovic
Potential Conviction Could Lead Donald Trump to Probation Review
© Getty Images

Donald Trump, the former President of the United States, has publicly decried the conditions of the Manhattan courtroom where he faces a hush money trial. With jury deliberations beginning, Trump might soon encounter additional indignities if convicted, including a mandatory review by New York City’s Department of Probation.

A potential conviction would involve more than just courtroom proceedings. Trump would be subjected to an interview by the probation office on the 10th floor of the Manhattan Criminal Courthouse, where he would discuss his personal history, mental health, and the circumstances surrounding his conviction. This process, often described as humbling by legal professionals, prepares presentencing reports for judges.

“If you think the courtroom is dingy, just wait until you go to the probation office,” commented Daniel Horwitz, a white-collar criminal defense attorney and former prosecutor.

Trump faces 34 felony counts of falsifying business records, connected to $130,000 in payments allegedly authorized by Trump to adult-film actress Stormy Daniels before the 2016 election. The payments were purportedly to silence Daniels about an encounter she claims to have had with Trump. Conviction on these charges carries a sentence of 16 months to four years in prison, but legal experts believe incarceration is unlikely given Trump’s age and lack of a criminal record.

Potential Legal and Political Implications

The trial, initiated on April 15, saw prosecutors argue that Trump falsely recorded the payments as legal expenses and improperly categorized them as campaign expenditures. Trump's defense claims these were personal payments meant to prevent family embarrassment. The jury must reach a unanimous decision for a conviction or acquittal, and a split decision could lead to a mistrial, allowing Manhattan District Attorney Alvin Bragg to potentially retry the case.

If convicted, Trump’s sentence would be determined by New York Supreme Court Justice Juan Merchan, who would consider input from both prosecution and defense in the presentencing report. While jail time is deemed improbable, alternatives like probation or home confinement present unique challenges, especially given Trump’s status as a former president and a leading presidential candidate.

New York Mayor Eric Adams has stated that the city’s Rikers Island jail complex is prepared if Trump is ordered to serve time. However, incarceration would not bar Trump from running for or serving as president, according to constitutional experts.

Potential Conviction Could Lead Donald Trump to Probation Review
Potential Conviction Could Lead Donald Trump to Probation Review© Getty Images

For a high-profile figure like Trump, probation would entail significant restrictions, including the need to clear any travel plans with a probation officer. Home confinement could see Trump residing at his Mar-a-Lago resort in Florida, with New York authorities coordinating with Florida counterparts to accommodate such an arrangement. Legal experts noted that while such scenarios are not uncommon, they require detailed approvals from probation officers.

Matthew Galluzzo, a former Manhattan prosecutor, highlighted the logistical difficulties of such arrangements, particularly for someone on the campaign trail. “Travel outside the country is difficult,” Galluzzo said, “That would be super awkward for someone on the campaign trail, but not impossible.”

Impact on the 2024 Presidential Campaign

Trump's campaign activities could be severely restricted if he is placed on probation. If Trump were to face home confinement, he could still participate in the political process, albeit in a limited capacity. He might hold news conferences and rallies remotely from Mar-a-Lago, maintaining his presence in the public eye.

The trial and potential sentencing loom over Trump’s campaign, with the first scheduled debate against President Joe Biden set for June 27 in Atlanta, followed by another on September 10 at a yet-undisclosed location. These debates are likely to occur before any potential sentencing.

Trump’s legal team would likely challenge a guilty verdict, requesting Judge Merchan to nullify it. However, experts suggest this is improbable, leading to the probation office compiling a presentencing report, including a biography of Trump. This confidential document, intended solely for the judge and lawyers, would significantly influence the sentencing outcome.

Throughout the trial, Trump has portrayed the prosecution as politically motivated, a narrative he would undoubtedly continue if convicted. His reaction to probation officers’ questions could further complicate his legal standing, particularly if he fails to acknowledge the truth as expected of convicts.

Defense attorney Jeremy Saland, also a former Manhattan prosecutor, emphasized the importance of honesty in these interviews, cautioning that denial of the charges could negatively impact the sentencing.

Legal experts suggest that, considering the nonviolent nature of his charges, Trump is unlikely to be detained while awaiting sentencing. Moreover, bail imposition is also improbable. His team would have a month to file an appeal notice and six months for the full appeal, potentially extending the legal process beyond the November 2024 presidential election.

Judge Merchan could grant Trump a conditional discharge, requiring him to avoid further legal offenses. Other potential penalties might include financial fines, community service, or counseling. Should the judge opt for home confinement, Trump could still conduct his campaign activities, albeit under significant restrictions.

Navigating the Legal Maze

If home confinement is imposed, Trump could maintain a virtual campaign presence. “He could be confined but go to Mar-a-Lago and hold a news conference every day, be on TV, hold rallies remotely,” Horwitz noted. “There’s a lot he can do as a candidate while under home confinement.”

The trial’s outcome and subsequent legal processes will undoubtedly impact Trump’s 2024 presidential campaign. As the jury deliberates, the nation watches closely, aware that the verdict will shape the political landscape in unprecedented ways. The legal and logistical challenges Trump may face highlight the complexities of holding a high-profile figure accountable while ensuring the integrity of the judicial process.

Donald Trump